How often and how successfully do top clubs invite their former players to coach?

In general, it is believed that most coaches are former players. But at the same time, great players rarely become top coaches. Therefore, the invitation of a former player to the coaching bridge is often quite an adventurous move. You can get 3 Champions Leagues in a row, like Zidane, and not work at all, like Seedorf. But now, especially after Guardiola and Zizou, there is such a trend as inviting former players to the coaching post.

The process of choosing a betting operator must be approached with all responsibility. Not only the size of the winnings, but also the guarantee of its receipt will depend on the decency of the company. Here https://bookmaker-ratings.com/ you will find a list of all bookmakers with reviews about each of them and you will be able to choose the right one for you.

Barcelona

We all know about the «Barcelona DNA», which results in a rather closed system of changing coaches, many of whom are former Catalan players. But for the appointments to be the majority – a small shock even for the fans. And in the 21st century, this trend is only intensifying – Guardiola, Vilanova, Enrique, Koeman, Xavi and even Valverde are all former Barca players.

The last successful Barca coach who has not played for her before is Rijkaard. But even before the 21st century there was Cruyff, or Reshak, who headed the club three times. But in the 20th century the situation, of course, was more even – there were Michels, and Menotti, and others. But the average duration of work is approximately the same – about 500 days.

Real Madrid

Perhaps we should start talking about «Los Blancos» DNA? The overwhelming advantage in trophies is provided not only by Zidane, but also by Del Bosque and Munoz, who won the very first European Cups. 9 such trophies were taken by former players, against only 5 (only) from non-former players. Yes, and the average duration of work is significantly longer for former players – about 800 days versus 450. But there is complete equality in appointments.

Atletico Madrid

And again, the advantage is on the side of the former players. Of course, the Simeone factor played a significant role here, who played at Atlético in the 90s, and then won a huge (by Atlético standards) number of trophies in the 2010s.

And in the 20th century there was also a former Aragonese player who led the team as many as 6 times. But Atlético’s only European Cup – the Cup Winners’ Cup – was not won by a former player – Jose Villalonga.

Manchester United

It turns out that in a club with a huge history and a bunch of legends, former players have never won a single significant trophy. What is significant there – not even a single second division or conditional Audi Cup, not a single trophy at all. The closest was Solskjaer, who lost the LE final to Villarreal.

Liverpool

We increase the average duration of the coach. Liverpool, compared to other clubs, did not have so many coaches in their history – 21 people. Again, the overwhelming advantage of non-former players on all fronts, except for trophies. A huge role in this was played by the former captain of the team, Bob Paisley, who took as many as 3 European Cups during his time at the club.

Manchester City

Surprisingly, the Sheikhs’ Club does not stand out much from the rest of the English clubs. Before the arrival of the sheikhs, former players quite often led the troubled City. After the arrival of the sheikhs – never. Therefore, one hundred percent of the trophies in the XXI century are easily explained. In general, former players won only 2 trophies at Manchester City – the FA Cup and the League Cup.

Summary

On average, top clubs are twice as likely to invite and succeed with non-former players when compared to former players. The gap in the average duration of work is not so significant, but a significant advantage still belongs to non-former players.