How can an energetic witness fall sick within two days – Justice Honyenuga fumes
“By court, I am equally surprised at the turn of events because the witness looked very energetic to fall sick within two days,”
Justice Clemence Jackson Honyenuga stunned the High Court on Wednesday when he suggested that a healthy person couldn’t get sick within days.
“By court, I am equally surprised at the turn of events because the witness looked very energetic to fall sick within two days,” he stated, sounding perplexed.
Justice Clemence Honyenuga, a Justice of the Supreme Court, who is sitting with additional responsibility as a High Court judge, has been hearing the ongoing trial of former COCOBOD boss, Dr. Stephen Opuni and businessman Seidu Agongo.
The case, which has traveled well over four years, has been cited as a politically motivated trial and has seen several, albeit unsuccessful, applications asking for the recusal of the judge.
When the case was called on May 18, Dr. Opuni’s counsel, Samuel Codjoe, told the court the defense witness, Samuel Torbie was unable to attend the day’s sitting because he is on admission at the emergency ward of the Ridge Hospital in Accra.
“Yesterday (Tuesday), he sent through another person to bring an envelope containing a Ridge Hospital excuse duty indicating that he is presently on admission at the emergency ward of the hospital. My Lord. I called him this morning after I opened and read the content of the envelope, and he said he is at the hospital and the emergency ward. He informed me that the Doctors are saying that they want to conduct a further test on him and that they have assured him that after they conduct this test, he will be released at the weekend,” lawyer Codjoe informed the court.
He further stated, “My lord, I asked that he gets a medical report so that I can show it to the court, but he told me that the doctors said they don’t give medical records to the court unless the court request it.”
Counsel also informed the court that he was willing to disclose the witness’ medical condition to the court in chambers.
“He informed me of what is wrong with him, but I cannot disclose his ailment because of confidentiality, and my lord, that explains why he is not in court today.”
Chief State Attorney Evelyn Keelson wondered why the illness was not stated on the excise duty.
According to her, the turn of events was “surprising” because “the witness appeared to be in very good health just a couple of days ago. My Lord, I also asked my learned friend why the excise duty does not indicate the illness the witness is suffering from, and he told me it was as a result of confidentiality.”
Justice Clemence Honyenuga, who appeared very unhappy, ruled on the development.
His posture appears to doubt the credibility of the excise duty from the state-owned Ridge Hospital.
“By court, I am equally surprised at the turn of events because the witness looked very energetic to fall sick within two days. It seems witnesses for the first accused usually fall sick during cross-examinations. I remember we had to adjourn this case for two weeks in the case of Dw1.
“I am equally surprised that on the excise duty form, there is no illness stated on it because before the court, there is nothing hidden in terms of sickness or otherwise.
“This is a criminal prosecution, and it has gone on for a whole four years, so, unfortunately, DW2 has to suffer the same fate as DW1.”
The judge, therefore, adjourned the case to Monday, May 23, 2022, for cross-examination to continue.
The witness, Samuel Torbie, is a chief cocoa farmer based in Assin Fosu who has been testifying about the efficacy of the Lithovit liquid fertilizer, a product he called “messiah”, which application helped him to over double his harvested cocoa beans.
The former COCOBOD Chief Executive, Dr. Stephen Opuni, and businessman Seidu Agongo, as well as Agricult Ghana Limited, are facing over 25 charges, including defrauding by pretenses, willfully causing financial loss to the state, corruption by public officers, and contravention of the Public Procurement Act.
They have pleaded not guilty to the charges and are on a GH¢300,000.00 self-recognizance bail each.
Source: angelonline.com
